Magic and power are second nature to teenage girls and the ambiguity of both suits them immensely. “The Scapegracers” is the best exploration of high school dynamics and teenage girls that I’ve seen for a good long time. Part of it could have been that I grew up in the same town and went to the same high school as the author, and every so often I felt like I recognized something from that. Even beyond that, however, everything from the raw emotion of Sideways Pike to the limited glimpses we got of teachers, felt meaty and real and true to what I remember of high school.

I really enjoyed that high school problems weren’t shortchanged for magic problems or vice versa. Balance in stories is something that is important to me as a reader and “Scapegracers” delivers that really well. The story of Sideways finding friends and finding a new niche in the high school hierarchy is part of Sideways finding her witchy coven and the world of magic opening to her even further, and the blend of the two leads to some incredible twists and turns.
The magic world “Scapegracers” sets up is so fantastic and unique. There are specters, an innate magical soul that only some people have, and book devils, who inhabit witch spellbooks and are trapped in vases if their book/coven is destroyed. It’s less about following rules exactly and more about finding how to make a set of guide rules work you with your own personal flair. It’s a wonderfully rich system that we’re only just beginning to scratch the surface of alongside Sideways and her friends.

The book is written in a limited first person point of view, and it is utilized to great effect, both in giving us Sideways’ complicated teenage internal monologue and for easing us into the magic world that exists alongside the mundane one. We only know what Sideways knows, and she’s really just starting out. At the beginning of the book, Sideways is doing her first big(ish) spell with other people, but by the end we’ve been introduced to witchfinders, a restaurant and art gallery that’s a front for a witch gathering place, and long established covens.

The book is also absolutely steeped in queerness. It was, for me, a refreshing departure from “this YA novel is queer, so it’s a coming out story.” There are some characters who are in the process of figuring themselves out, and those subplots are great and well done, but Sideways, our point of view, has got herself figured out as a lesbian, and she’s got a great life with her gay dads. There’s some homophobia, but it’s limited, and falls in with what I would consider standard bullying/douchebaggery for a high school story. We also get to see Sideways and company rage and be vengeful about it, which we love to see.
If you’re a fan of “Buffy the Vampire Slayer,” especially the early seasons, or just generally enjoy all things queer and witchy, you will like this book. And of course, once you’ve finished “Scapegracers,” you should go pick up the sequel, “The Scratch Daughters,” which I started immediately upon finishing the first book. It really is just that good.
If you enjoy what I do please consider supporting me Patreon or buying me a Kofi.